Skip to main content
How to Replace a Shower Knob or Handle: A DIY Guide

How to Replace a Shower Knob or Handle: A DIY Guide

Intermediate
35 mins
5 Steps
3 Items

About This Project

This project details how to replace a shower knob or handle. It involves five steps: 1) Turning off the shower's water supply by locating the shut-off valves and turning them clockwise. If individual valves are unavailable, shut off the main water supply. 2) Removing the old shower handle screw(s), often hidden beneath a decorative cap, which needs to be carefully pried off, followed by unscrewing the handle screw(s). 3) Removing the old shower handle by gently pulling it off the valve stem, using a handle puller tool if necessary. 4) Installing the new shower handle, aligning it with the valve stem and securing it with the previously removed screw(s). Avoid over-tightening. 5) Testing the new shower handle and checking for leaks by slowly turning the water supply back on. If leaks occur, tighten fittings and retest.

T

Based on content from

This Old House
2.2M subscribers· +23 others
View Channel

Best for homeowners and DIY enthusiasts.

Tools & Materials

HDX 3-1/4 in. 6-in-1 Screwdriver 120SD12D

HDX 3-1/4 in. 6-in-1 Screwdriver 120SD12D

Milwaukee 4 in. x 1/4 in. Slotted Flat Head Screwdriver with Cushion Grip MT206

Milwaukee 4 in. x 1/4 in. Slotted Flat Head Screwdriver with Cushion Grip MT206

ESCO Automotive U-Joint Puller 40302

ESCO Automotive U-Joint Puller 40302

Steps

Common Problems

Use a thin-bladed tool and be gentle to avoid breaking the plastic clips on the cap.

Solution: To avoid this issue: Be mindful of this warning and take appropriate precautions.

Incorrect Allen wrench size prevents handle removal or reattachment.

Solution: Keep a set of both metric and imperial Allen wrenches handy, as faucet hardware can vary.

Make sure the sink drain is closed before loosening the set screw to avoid losing it.

Solution: To avoid this issue: Be mindful of this warning and take appropriate precautions.

Stubborn shower handles can crack or damage the valve stem if pried off incorrectly.

Solution: A handle puller is the recommended tool for stubborn handles to prevent cracking the handle or damaging the valve stem.

Avoid overtightening the packing nut as it can damage the new washer and cause another leak.

Solution: To avoid this issue: Be mindful of this warning and take appropriate precautions.

Cross-threading can damage shower knob components if not hand-tightened first.

Solution: Hand-tighten components first to prevent cross-threading, which can damage the parts.

Shower handle won't turn or is damaged due to misaligned splines.

Solution: Ensure the splines are properly engaged before tightening to prevent misalignment or damage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the most important safety precaution to take before replacing my shower handle?

Always ensure the water supply to your shower is completely turned off before starting. This prevents accidental flooding and potential water damage. If individual shut-off valves for your shower are unavailable, you must turn off the main water supply to your entire home.

While a flat-head screwdriver is usually sufficient for removing decorative caps and screws, a handle puller tool can be incredibly useful. If your old handle is stuck due to corrosion or mineral buildup, a puller will help remove it without damaging the valve stem or the handle itself.

For a beginner, this project typically takes 30 minutes to an hour, assuming no major issues like heavily corroded parts. The cost for a new shower handle can vary widely, from $20 for basic models to $100+ for higher-end or brand-specific designs, depending on your existing faucet's requirements.

Shower handles are not universal; they often need to be compatible with your existing faucet brand and valve stem type. Double-check your new handle's compatibility with your shower's make and model. Ensure the handle is fully seated onto the valve stem and that the set screw is tightened securely, but avoid over-tightening which can strip threads.

The set screw is frequently hidden. Carefully inspect the handle's base or front for a small decorative cap or a tiny plastic plug. You can often pry these off gently with a thin flat-head screwdriver or a utility knife to reveal the screw underneath.

Immediately turn off the water supply again. A leak usually indicates the handle wasn't properly seated or the connection isn't tight enough. Ensure the handle is fully pushed onto the valve stem, and that any associated screws, gaskets, or escutcheon plates are snug and correctly aligned, then retest slowly.