Skip to main content

Debating Diesel vs. Gas for Business

1:23
16:32
82.7K views

At 1:23 in

Gas VS Diesel work truck. 7 years Later....

What happens here

Stanley shares his apprehension about buying a diesel truck due to concerns about Diesel Exhaust Fluid (DEF) systems. He mentions that three people, including a mechanic and a dealership employee, advised him against it. These individuals cited issues with DEF freezing in colder climates (above a certain latitude) and the requirement to start the truck 30 minutes in advance to thaw the DEF, which is impractical for immediate work needs like plowing snow. Jason agrees that if low mileage (e.g., 15,000 miles/year) is expected, a diesel is not worth it for business due to the added cost and maintenance of the DEF system. He suggests diesels are only cost-effective for high-mileage users (e.g., 25,000-30,000 miles/year) who can utilize their longer engine life (300,000 miles). They lament that government involvement post-2012 has complicated diesel truck technology, leading to more problems. Stanley notes that, in his experience, the truck's body and components (excluding the engine) tend to wear out around 100,000-150,000 miles, making the extended engine life of a diesel less beneficial if the rest of the truck needs significant repairs. He calls this the "nickel and dime factor," where fixing non-engine components becomes more expensive than the truck's worth, suggesting work trucks are almost disposable after a certain mileage. Jason concurs that the DEF system itself "sucks" due to additional costs and frequent refills.

Goal: Discuss the practicalities and issues of owning diesel trucks for commercial use.

What they say

Hide

oh i love it did you have any electrical problems with that whatsoever mine is always have an electrical problem no no i've had diesels and i've had very good luck with those and like i said i don't i always no i was gonna buy a diesel truck and three people have talked me out of it dusty was one talked me out of it a mechanic that i didn't know from adam that worked on diesel trucks talked me out of it and the dealer talked me out of it it depends on what you're doing with the truck and how many miles you're gonna put on it if you're gonna drive like with my business when i got it it had diesels but since i drove so little miles 15 000 miles a year yeah i would not buy diesels again for my business but if you're gonna put a lot of miles on it i would buy diesel because you get three hundred thousand when i was doing estimating all that i'm putting 25 30 000 a year now they're worried about death shortages and if you live above a certain latitude i wouldn't get one either because your death is freezing up i was told i was told by the dealer he sat next to me and said hey you know you know how you get around the problem with the death and i'm like i didn't know there was a problem with death okay how do you get around it he says well you know it's freezing up on guys and i said i didn't know that either but how do you get around that he's like oh just about 30 minutes before you're going to drive it go out and start it up so it can thaw the the death out i'm like how's that work when i got to go plow and i'm like hey can you get here like 10 minutes ago well yeah just give me 30 minutes for my truck to get ready to go to work i know that's yeah and then i i would say if that's the issue then absolutely but i i never had issues and for my business i wouldn't buy diesel yeah yeah no gas because i you buy these salt for the mileage is what i would do yep there's no uh and the equipment's getting lighter and we're using less bobcats for what we did you know and stuff like that so that the gas engines can pull it fine yeah you know that's what i'm finding too it it was you know back in the day when they made a really good decent decision now the company's a great deal don't get me wrong but when 2012 happened and the government got involved yeah they messed it up imagine that right shocker there shocker there they don't make anything better they may get worse so like on on my truck would i find i buy i went with all gassers myself and what i found is that um the…

Auto-generated from the video audio.