Skip to main content

Remove the Damaged Steel Ring — Position and Secure the Repair Ring

Beginner4 hours

Part of project

How to Repair a Broken Toilet Flange with a Repair Ring · Step 3 of 6

Helpful?

In this video

To begin the repair, the old damaged or rusted steel ring must be removed from the PVC toilet flange. This is typically done by prying it off with a pry bar or cutting it with a suitable tool. Care must be taken to only remove the metal ring and not damage the underlying PVC body that it sits in.

Goal: Toilet Removal (No Floor Damage)

  • Pry carefully to avoid cracking the PVC flange body, which would necessitate a more complex repair.

Used in this video

  • Pry Bar (Pry Bar Type: Flat pry bar)Prying off the old, damaged metal ring from the PVC flange.
  • Reciprocating Saw (Reciprocating Saw Blade Type: Metal cutting blade, Power Source: Cordless) · optionalCutting through the old metal ring if it cannot be pried off.
  • Safety Glasses (Safety Glasses Material: Polycarbonate)Protecting eyes from flying debris while prying or cutting.
  • Gloves (Gloves Material: Latex)Protecting hands from sharp, rusted metal.
12.3K views355-15 minutes
This Old House

2.2M subscribers

View Channel

FAQs

The project is rated 'beginner' but has a 4-hour estimate. What makes it beginner-friendly, and what contributes to the time needed?

This project is beginner-friendly because it doesn't require specialized plumbing skills, just careful step-following and patience. The 4 hours account for draining/removing the toilet, thorough cleaning of the flange area, precise repair ring placement, and careful reinstallation with a new wax seal, especially for first-timers.

Are all the listed tools absolutely necessary, or are there any I might already have that could serve as alternatives?

Essential tools include an adjustable wrench for water lines and bolts, a drill for securing the repair ring, and a putty knife for scraping off old wax. While specific brands are listed, generic versions of these tools are usually sufficient. A sturdy bucket and sponges are also critical for water management and cleanup.

What are the most common pitfalls or mistakes DIYers make during this repair, and how can I avoid them?

A common mistake is not thoroughly cleaning the old flange area, leading to poor adhesion or an uneven seal. Another is improperly seating the new wax ring or overtightening closet bolts, which can crack the porcelain base of the toilet. Ensure the flange is dry and level before installing the repair ring, and tighten bolts gradually and evenly.

What are the key safety precautions I should take when removing and reinstalling a heavy toilet?

Always shut off the water supply to the toilet and flush to empty the tank and bowl as much as possible before attempting removal. Toilets are heavy and awkward, so lift with your legs or get help from another person to avoid back injury. Wear appropriate gloves to protect against unsanitary conditions and potential sharp edges from the broken flange.