Brooklyn Cocktail Recipe: A Rye Whiskey Classic
About This Project
1. **Chill:** Fill a mixing glass with ice to chill it. 2. **Combine Ingredients:** Measure and add 2 oz rye whiskey, 1 oz dry vermouth, 1/2 oz Amer Picon (or Amaro CioCiaro), and 1/4 oz maraschino liqueur to the chilled mixing glass. 3. **Stir:** Add ice to the mixing glass. Stir for 30 seconds until chilled. 4. **Strain:** Strain into a chilled coupe or cocktail glass. 5. **Garnish:** Optionally garnish with a maraschino cherry or lemon twist.
Best for homeowners and DIY enthusiasts with familiarity with power tools.
Tools & Materials
Neat Pour Glass, Hand-Blown - Imperfect
Ice Maker for Clear Spheres
Japanese-Style Jigger
Bourbon whiskey
The Stirred Cocktail Set - Mix 'N Match
Amaro
Neat Pour Glass, Hand-Blown - Imperfect
<p class=""><span style="color: #000000;"><strong><i>Superficial imperfections are present on this product (think minor exterior marks or a slightly wobbly base). This is reflected in the discounted price. Embrace their Wabi Sabi and save some cash! 40% off taken at checkout<br></i></strong></span></p> <p class=""><span style="color: #000000;">There are few better ways to savor a statement dram than with these gorgeous hand-blown glasses. Made here in the Pacific Northwest, we use two different molds to create the three distinctive styles.</span></p> <p class=""><span style="color: #000000;">The design for the foot is inspired by the many shades of amber, ruby and gold we find in the best whiskeys, cognacs, and other great liquids best enjoyed neat. The design of the glass is meant to concentrate all the aromatics like that perfect floral bouquet.</span></p> <p class=""><span style="color: #000000;">Every batch is just a little different. Revel in the uniqueness of each glass!</span></p> <p class="">Sold Individually</p> <p class=""><span style="color: #000000;">Comes in three styles: Diamond, Spiral, and Pinstripe</span></p> <p class=""><span style="color: #000000;">Hand wash only.</span></p>
Ice Maker for Clear Spheres
<p class="">Finally, an easy method for making clear ice balls! Cloudy ice is caused by ice freezing from the outside-in causing air to be trapped within the ice. The Clearsphere system uses a directional freezing method to control the direction that water freezes, pushing all the air out of the ice ball. - Makes two (2) 2.5 inch ice spheres - Molds are BPA free and dishwasher safe - Stackable - 5 piece system Includes silicone ice ball mold, insulated freezing chamber, and integrated ice ball storage box.</p> <p class=""><strong>Directions:</strong><br>1) Place plastic tub into foam box, fill with warm water to the inner fill line.<br>2) Combine two silicone molds and slowly push completely down and water overlows.<br>3) Place upright in freezer for 24-30 hours.<br>4) Remove from freezer and let it rest for 5 minutes. Peel out mold by pulling on both of handles on one of the ends. Repeat on other side.<br>5) Separate the silicone molds - serve or store for later.</p>
Japanese-Style Jigger
<p class="" style="white-space: pre-wrap;">Elegant design and a bartender favorite, this Japanese-style jigger measures 1 oz and 2 oz pours.</p> <p class="" style="white-space: pre-wrap;">Our version comes in seven finishes: Silver, Copper, Gold, Gunmetal Black, Matte Black, Antique Brass, and Rainbow Chrome.</p> <p class="" style="white-space: pre-wrap;">Each one has internal measures (.25, .5oz and .75oz on the 1oz side; 1.5oz on the 2oz side). THAT'S RIGHT! We have a 1/4 oz line!</p> <p style="white-space: pre-wrap;" class=""> <strong>While our silver version is perfectly dishwasher safe, we recommend handwashing any of the other finishes to prolong the life of those coatings.</strong></p>
Bourbon whiskey
bourbon whiskey
The Stirred Cocktail Set - Mix 'N Match
What better way to start building the ultimate home bar than with our Stirred Cocktail Set. We only use premium tools for the best experience. This makes a perfect gift for any home bartender (including yourself!) <p class="">The set includes:</p> <p class=""><strong>- <a href="https://bullinchinapdx.com/products/hammered-glass-mixing-vessel" target="_blank">"Flagship" Mixing Glass</a> (20oz/600ml) - durable, seamless, AND it's got looks<br></strong></p> <p class=""><strong>- <a href="https://bullinchinapdx.com/products/teardrop-barspoons-30cm" target="_blank">Teardrop Barspoon</a> (12"/30cm) - versatile, weighted, and balanced<br></strong></p> <p class=""><strong>- <a href="https://bullinchinapdx.com/products/bell-jigger" title="Bell Jigger" target="_blank">2:1 Bell Jigger</a> (w/internal measures) - premium, ergonomic, and accurate<br></strong></p> <p class=""><strong>- Made in PDX <a href="https://bull-in-china-pdx.myshopify.com/products/new-hawthorne-strainer" target="_blank">Hawthorne Strainer</a> - BIC Originals</strong></p> <p class=""><strong>- Premium Bull In China Gift Box</strong></p> <p>Some people believe Julep Strainers are the only ones meant to use for Stirred Cocktails, but we respectfully disagree. The Hawthorne Strainer is a versatile tool that works just as well for stirred cocktails as it does for shaken ones—which is why we’ve included it here. And ours is the only one on the market that is made right here, in the United States. It fits perfectly atop our signature Bull in China Mixing Glass, our shaker tins, or even most pint glasses.</p> <p class="">Customize your set with a choice of finishes for most items. <em>Price changes accordingly.<br></em></p> <p class=""><i>Want to step up a Level? </i>Check out the <a href="https://bull-in-china-pdx.myshopify.com/products/bundle-products-stirred-cocktail">Artisan Stirred Cocktail Set</a>.</p>
Amaro
amaro
Steps
Common Problems
Over-stirring dilutes the Brooklyn cocktail too much.
Solution: Do not over-stir, as this can dilute the drink excessively.
Inaccurate measurements lead to a poorly balanced, unpalatable cocktail.
Solution: Ensure accurate measurements for the best flavor balance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need all the exact, specialized bar tools listed for this Brooklyn Cocktail, or can I use more common kitchen equipment?
While the listed tools enhance the cocktail-making experience and precision, you can absolutely start with common kitchen alternatives. A measuring spoon set or shot glass can substitute for a jigger, any tall glass for a mixing glass, and a regular spoon for a barspoon. However, investing in a good Hawthorne strainer is highly recommended for a clean, pulp-free drink.
Amer Picon is difficult to find in my area. What are the best alternative liqueurs if Amaro CioCiaro isn't available either?
Amer Picon is a unique bitter orange liqueur. If Amaro CioCiaro isn't an option, you could try other amari with a prominent bitter orange profile, such as Ramazzotti or Cynar, though they will alter the flavor profile slightly. Another approach is to combine a dash of orange bitters with a lighter, slightly less bitter amaro to approximate the desired complexity.
What's the secret to getting a perfectly chilled but not diluted stirred cocktail like the Brooklyn?
The key is to use plenty of fresh, dense ice in your mixing glass and stir consistently for the full 30 seconds. Pre-chilling your serving glass is also crucial, as it keeps the drink colder for longer without additional dilution. Avoid using chipped or 'wet' ice from melted cubes, as this will lead to a watery drink.
This recipe is rated 'beginner.' What's the most common mistake a novice might make, and how can I avoid it for the Brooklyn Cocktail?
The most common beginner mistake is either under-chilling the cocktail or over-diluting it. Ensure both your mixing glass and serving glass are properly chilled before you begin. Use fresh, solid ice cubes for stirring and strain promptly after the recommended stir time to prevent excessive melt.
How much should I expect to spend on ingredients if I'm building a home bar from scratch just for this Brooklyn Cocktail?
The initial investment can be significant as you'll need full bottles of rye whiskey, dry vermouth, maraschino liqueur, and an Amer Picon substitute. Expect to spend anywhere from $100-$200+ for quality bottles. While a single drink seems expensive upfront, these are foundational spirits that will allow you to make many other classic cocktails.
Are there any specific safety precautions I should take when mixing cocktails, especially regarding glassware and alcohol?
Always handle glassware with care to avoid chips or breaks, especially when stirring vigorously or washing. Be mindful of the alcohol content in cocktails and drink responsibly. Also, ensure your workspace is clean and organized to prevent spills and cross-contamination, maintaining good hygiene.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__simply_recipes__uploads__2020__08__Gimlet-Cocktail-LEAD-4-d7e46f7400b24163aa7049332cac56d9.jpg)