Skip to main content
Between the Sheets Cocktail Recipe

Between the Sheets Cocktail Recipe

Intermediate
15 minutes
4 Steps
10 Items

About This Project

To make a Between the Sheets cocktail, first, fill a cocktail shaker with ice. Then, add 1.5 oz light rum, 1 oz cognac, 1 oz Cointreau, and 0.75 oz fresh lemon juice. Secure the lid and shake until chilled. Finally, strain the mix into a chilled coupe glass.

S

Based on content from

Stesso - Bull In China
2 subscribers· +7 others
View Channel

Best for homeowners and DIY enthusiasts with familiarity with power tools.

Tools & Materials

Shaken Cocktail Set - Mix 'N Match

Shaken Cocktail Set - Mix 'N Match

Ice cubes

Ice cubes

Japanese-Style Jigger

Japanese-Style Jigger

Feuerzangenbowle

Feuerzangenbowle

Cognac

Cognac

Curacao

Curacao

Steps

Common Problems

Your cocktail ends up with unwanted ice shards and pulp.

Solution: Double straining removes ice chips and small pieces of fruit or herbs.

Splashing and uneven ingredient distribution during cocktail mixing.

Solution: Pour steadily to maintain control and prevent splashing.

Watery, diluted cocktails result from using low-quality ice.

Solution: Use high-quality ice for the best results.

Your cocktail will be diluted and lukewarm.

Solution: Be generous with the ice.

Cocktail dilutes too quickly with small ice.

Solution: Use larger ice cubes.

Do not use crushed or shaved ice unless making a frozen drink.

Solution: To avoid this issue: Be mindful of this warning and take appropriate precautions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need specific bar tools like a Japanese-Style Jigger and Hawthorne Strainer for this recipe, or can I use common kitchen alternatives?

While specialized bar tools ensure precision and efficiency, you can certainly start with kitchen alternatives. Use standard measuring spoons or a small liquid measuring cup for ingredients, and a small kitchen sieve or even a slotted spoon can work in place of a Hawthorne strainer to hold back ice.

For the authentic 'Between the Sheets' flavor, it's best to stick to light rum, cognac, and Cointreau. While you could technically use other orange liqueurs for Cointreau, it has a distinct flavor profile that contributes significantly. Substituting the base spirits would create a different cocktail altogether.

Ensure your shaker is filled at least two-thirds with fresh ice, preferably large cubes. Shake vigorously for about 15-20 seconds until the outside of the shaker feels very cold and frosted. Don't under-shake, which leads to warmth, or over-shake, which causes excessive dilution.

A coupe glass is traditional and elegant, but any stemmed cocktail glass will work well. A chilled martini glass or even a small, elegant wine glass can serve as a good substitute. The key is to pre-chill your serving glass to maintain the cocktail's cold temperature.

As a beginner, your first few attempts might take slightly longer, perhaps 20-25 minutes, as you familiarize yourself with measuring and shaking techniques. However, the steps are quite simple, and you'll quickly become efficient enough to complete it within the 15-minute estimate.

The initial cost of purchasing light rum, cognac, and Cointreau can be an investment if you don't have them in your home bar. However, these are versatile spirits used in many classic cocktails, making them valuable additions for expanding your mixology repertoire.